Monday, December 22, 2008

Interesting List for All Time Sluggers

The things one will do in the middle of a blizzard. With time to kill, the Fan took all the sluggers with 400 or more home runs and made an all time OPS list. For those who don't know. OPS equals On Base Percentage (OBP) plus Slugging Percentage. Slugging Percentage equals Total Bases divided by At Bats. The list is interesting:


  1. Ruth 1.159

  2. Ted Williams 1.116

  3. Gehrig 1.074

  4. Bonds 1.051

  5. Foxx 1.034

  6. M. Ramirez 1.004

  7. McGwire .982

  8. Mantle .979

  9. Musial .976

  10. F. Thomas .974

  11. A. Rodriguez .967

  12. Thome .966

  13. Chipper Jones .956

  14. Bagwell .948

  15. Ott .943
    Mays .943

  16. Aaron .929
    Delgado .929

  17. Robinson .926

  18. Piazza .922

  19. Griffey .920

  20. Snider .919

  21. Sheffield .910

  22. Schmidt .907

  23. J. Gonzalez .904

  24. McCovey .889

  25. Stargell .889

  26. Palmeiro .886

  27. McGriff .886

  28. E. Matthews .886

  29. Killebrew .885

  30. Sosa .878

  31. Canseco .868

  32. Billy Williams .853

  33. R. Jackson .846

  34. Yastrzemski .841

  35. Murray .835

  36. Banks .831

  37. Winfield .828

  38. Dawson .805

  39. Darrell Evans .792

  40. C. Ripken .787

  41. Kingman .780

Some comments about the list: First, many of the current players on the list will drop if they continue playing past their peak. For example, Sheffield showed a big drop in productivity this past year and his lifetime OPS dropped and will continue to do so as he plays out his career. The same can be said for players who played longer than they should have such as Willie Mays, Winfield and Reggie Jackson. Secondly, the list proves out what the Fan has always believed: Cal Ripken, Andre Dawson and Carl Yastrzemski were vastly overrated as sluggers shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame. Hey, if that statement is true for Dave Kingman, it is true for Ripken and Darrell Evans.

The surprises on the list are Mantle at number 8 and Manny Ramirez at number 6. There is no surprise that Musial is at number 9. He is the most overlooked superstar and is the greatest living player of the bygone era. If OPS is more important than home run totals as most stat heads now consider it is, then the case seems to be made that Jeff Bagwell is a hall of famer as is Mike Piazza. It also seems to indicate that Ruth, Gehrig and Ted Williams are the greatest sluggers of all time.

No comments: